« The Proof Is In The Peripherals: May 9-15 | Main | RotoAuthority Unscripted: Who or What is Drew Pomeranz? »

RotoAuthority League Update: Blockbuster Week

The RotoAuthority League is a highly competitive 12-team fantasy baseball league run by Tim Dierkes. The settings consist of standard 5 X 5 Rotisserie scoring and 23-man lineups along with 4 bench spots. In an effort to keep owners interested as well as to infuse new blood into the league, the teams that finish below 8th place are kicked out of the league each year. The author of this column just hopes he isn't one of them.

Just about all of the trades covered last week were one-for-one deals. This past week, however, we witnessed several trades featuring multiple players on each side of the transaction. In general, I prefer to make moves that are smaller in size, as it's simply easier to analyze the categorical effects on my roster. Moreover, the greater the scope of a deal, the increased chance of highway robbery. Then again, I guess that's not a bad thing, assuming you're the one committing grand larceny. Let's take a look at the big deals from this past week.

05/05 - Men With Wood agrees to trade Ryan Zimmerman and Corey Dickerson to the Bombers for Everth Cabrera and Eric Young

The Bombers currently lead the league in the SB category, so they could afford to ship Cabrera and Young out of town. Before checking the full standings, I assumed Men With Wood must have had a need for speed; however, the former champion actually lies in third place in that category right now. Accordingly, this may have been a value-based move for Men With Wood, at least to a certain extent. Although Dickerson had a big day at the plate on Saturday, he still doesn't crack the lineup everyday. In effect, this trade will ultimately come down to the return date for Zimmerman. Overall then, the Bombers are gambling on Zimmerman's health while dealing from a surplus of speed.

05/07 - Pulling Brzenk agrees to trade Justin Verlander, Ervin Santana, and Joe Smith to Brewsterville Bruins for Alex Cobb and LaTroy Hawkins

As I mentioned, the more players included in a deal, the greater the possibility that the trade swings more and more in one direction. Well, for my money this was a great move by the Brewsterville Bruins. I have a ton of respect for Pulling Brzenk; after all, he won the league last year and is currently in second place. Clearly this owner is doing something right. Moreover, I'm very bullish on Cobb; in fact, I've made an effort to acquire him in all my leagues while he's on the DL. I also understand that you have to overpay to acquire a closer via trade in the RotoAuthority League; that's just how the market has been set.

Concessions aside, however, I still think the Bruins did very well here. I know Verlander's early skills are worrisome, but he's still viewed as a no-doubt ace on the fantasy marketplace. Santana, though, may be the true prize of this haul. The move to the NL has done wonders for the verteran right-hander, as his skills thus far have been electric. If we break this deal down, I think it's safe to say that Santana is at worst equivalent in value to Cobb, especially given that the Rays right-hander will still be out a couple more weeks.

That leaves a swap of Hawkins for Verlander and Smith. I'm sorry, but that just doesn't pass the smell test to me. If Hawkins were an elite closer, I think you could justify the move for Pulling Brzenk; however, the Rockies closer is actually harmful in the strikeout category, as he's currently fanning just 10% of batters. Smith picked up a save on Saturday and still may be the closer for the Angels. Even if we assume Frieri usurps the role eventually, Smith still has to rank as one of the most valuable middle relievers going forward. After desconstructing this deal then, the Bruins practically acquired Verlander for free.

05/09 - Smell the Glove agree to trade Jonathan Lucroy and David Robertson to Pulling Brzenk for Matt Wieters, Daniel Murphy, and Nathan Eovaldi

Another trade, another closer acquisition for Pulling Brzenk. Given that Wieters was placed on the DL yesterday, you might have a slight preference for the Lucroy over the Orioles backstop. Overall, though, I think Lucroy and Wieters are virtually interchangeable commodities when healthy. As I mentioned last week, I'm a fan of Robertson and feel he has what it takes to be a borderline-elite closer. Still, I think Commissioner Dierkes did well here in acquiring Murphy and Eovaldi. At this point Murphy has established himself as a solid middle infield option who contributes a little bit across the board. Eovaldi, though, looks like the hidden gem here. He's always thrown hard, but now the results are catching up to the stuff. The early skills are truly elite: he currently ranks seventh in the game in SIERA. In a pitcher-friendly park, Eovaldi should be able to put together a solid season. Ultimately then, I prefer this deal in a vacuum for the Commish assuming Wieters isn't out too long, but Pulling Brzenk did well given league context.




Site Map     Contact     About     Advertise     Privacy Policy     MLB Trade Rumors     Rss Feed