« The Proof Is In The Peripherals: July 4-10 | Main | Stock Watch: Guys Named Davis (And a Surprising Quantity of Mets) »

Closer Updates: Not Exactly the Best

If you don't own a Diamondbacks closer, it's probably been a pretty quiet week for you. Given that, we'll take a quick look at some closers who may have seen changes in their value, and examine the situation in Arizona, before tackling the most exciting possible post-July-4th topic: disappointing closers. A couple weeks ago, we looked at the best* closers around baseball and determined whether or not we would want each one on our teams going forward. Back then, we promised to follow up with the rest of baseball's stoppers, so here we are.

*Note: actually, we looked at those closers who had saved the most games thus far. Some (**cough, cough**, Tom Wilhelmsen) were not even arguably among "the best."


J.J. Putz just hasn't been a good investment this year. Bad pitching, seven weeks of injury, and now he blows the save and loses his job in his first outing back. I guess there's a reason most teams ease returned stoppers back into the ninth. For now, Putz will work to build himself up and Heath Bell has un-lost the closing gig. Hold on to both for now, keeping Bell until Putz shows a strong hold on the job, and not dropping Putz unless he scuffles in middle relief for an extended period. The whole situation makes this Bell owner pretty happy his father beat him to snagging Putz off the waiver wire....


The aforementioned (and afore-maligned) Tom Wilhelmsen locked down his 17th save Wednesday, and looks to be getting future chances. If he got dropped (I dropped him) in your league, pick him back up if you need saves. 


Sure, Kevin Gregg blew his first save, but he came back with another winner for the Cubs. The chance that he gets traded to a contender to set up is pretty high, but in case he doesn't, he could be a good trade target, as this article suggests a solid reason for his much-improved control.


Francisco Rodriguez nailed down another save Wednesday. He's gotten a lot more chances than Jim Henderson lately, and it may be proper to consider him the real closer in Milwaukee. Trade for him with care, however, as he's a good candidate for a real-life trade into the 7th or 8th inning.

Less than the Best

It's worth noting (briefly) that I'm not including closers who've bounced in and out of the job, those who've spent significant time injured, or who just got the job. Those guys get plenty of face time in this space anyway.

Can't Complain--or Shouldn't, at Least

Ernesto Frieri, 21 SV

Frieri is what he is and does what he does. Specifically, he strikes tons of people out, and walks tons of people. He's like the old Armando Benitez, a good Carlos Marmol, or Aroldis Chapman-lite. It seems to work, and the Angels are more likely to reload for next year than try to rebuild.

Glen Perkins, 20 SV

Perkins has been a boss, but you should trade him away. Why? Because the Twins are awful and he could fetch a serious return on the real-life trade market. Deal him first, just in case, because most of the closers he'd replace don't pitch for the teams that will be buyers at the deadline. (Except the Tigers, but an in-division trade is a bit much to hope for.)

Grant Balfour, 20 SV

The world's most appropriately named person (seriously, I bet his parents were Nolan Ryan fans and hoped he'd grow up to be the all-time leader in walks issued) has given owners none of the stress they (we) received last year. Luckily for his owners, the A's are firmly in contention and won't be dealing him away. He's a great trade target if you can pry him away from his owners.

It's Been an Interesting Ride, Hasn't it?

Greg Holland, 18 SV

Quick: who's got the second best K/9% among closers. Yup, it's Holland, who's only a little behind Chapman and nearly a full point ahead of third-place Jason Grilli. Holland's owners should hope Kansas City can retain delusions hopes of contention, because he could make a great trade piece. He's been so good that I'd gamble on him until and unless trade rumors heat up about him.

Casey Janssen, 17 SV

This guy has quietly pitched very well up North. The Blue Jays may not be contending this year, but the team they built in the offseason wasn't built for this year only. Unless the rumor mill says otherwise, expect Janssen to keep the job. He's a good one to deal for, if worried owners predict a real life trade.

Jose Veras, 17 SV

Veras went practically undrafted in many leagues this year, as the hapless Astros weren't expected to offer enough save chances for him to be relevant. Well, he is. He's worth targeting, especially as a throw-in for a larger fantasy trade. Unfortunately, Veras is very vulnerable to leaving the Astros for the middle of a contender's bullpen.

Fernando Rodney, 17 SV

I'm pretty sure fantasy owners who drafted Rodney early didn't expect Jose Veras to have matched his save total at this point in the season. Here we are, though. It's clear that Rodney isn't the guy he looked like last year (surprise), but he isn't as bad as he once was, either. Expect him to close all year on the contending Rays team; he's a good one to target in trade, as his owner is likely still disappointed in his production.

There's Always Next Year the Second Half

Steve Cishek, 16 SV

Cishek might get the award for Most Likely to Be Traded, as the Marlins are going nowhere and have a compulsive desire to trade anyone making more than half a million dollars every deadline. If you can get any value for him, I'd cut bait on this Fish. Unfortunately, you probably can't, so your best option is just to ride it out and enjoy the few saves while you can.

Jonathan Papelbon, 16 SV

Papelbon is probably the best trade target out there right now. He's just gone through a pretty rough stretch, which might lower his value just a bit. More importantly, he's the only closer that might be on the market that will close just about anywhere he gets traded. Even if the Phillies don't improve in the second half, it's very likely that he gets (and converts) plenty more save chances. 

Huston Street, 15 SV

Street has already spent injured time, depressing his save total. While he could be traded, San Diego isn't out of it just yet and might not be hoping to sell. Of course, Street has been horrid this year, with a 4.94 K/9 and an eye-popping 7.59 FIP. The good news is that his xFIP is only 4.90. If you can find a buyer, deal him away. 

Bobby Parnell, 14 SV

Parnell has shown great control and hasn't let a single ball out of the yard. Pretty impressive, but not good enough to net him the lowest save total for anyone who's kept the job all year. At least he isn't under the shadow of Frank Francisco anymore. There haven't been any trade rumors about Parnell yet, but the Mets aren't exactly playing for the 2013 Series. Like Papelbon, he's likely to receive more save chances in the second half.

Rafael Betancourt, 14 SV

Betancourt has been his usual fragile-but-good self this year. With Colorado just 2.5 games back, don't expect the Rockies to try dealing him away just yet. That makes him a better trade candidate than most of the pitchers on this list.

Site Map     Contact     About     Advertise     Privacy Policy     MLB Trade Rumors     Rss Feed